Reviewer Guidelines
Computational Intelligence in Modern Power Systems follows a single-anonymous (single-blind) peer-review process. Reviewer identities remain confidential, while author identities are disclosed to reviewers.
Reviewer Selection
Each manuscript requiring external peer review is normally evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with relevant subject expertise.
Reviewers are selected based on their qualifications, research expertise, methodological knowledge, and absence of conflicts of interest.
Confidentiality
All manuscripts and information received during peer review must be treated as confidential. Reviewers must not share, reproduce, discuss, or use unpublished manuscript information for personal or professional advantage.
Reviewer Responsibilities
- Provide objective, impartial, and constructive evaluations.
- Assess the originality and significance of the work.
- Evaluate methods, models, algorithms, experiments, simulations, and analyses as applicable.
- Assess whether the results support the conclusions.
- Evaluate the clarity and reproducibility of the research.
- Assess the quality and relevance of references.
- Identify possible plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabrication, falsification, image manipulation, or other misconduct.
- Declare actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest.
- Decline the review when they lack sufficient expertise or cannot complete the review within the required period.
Evaluation Criteria
- Originality and significance
- Scientific and technical quality
- Methodological and computational soundness
- Quality of algorithms, models, simulations, experiments, or analyses, where applicable
- Clarity and organization
- Validity and interpretation of results
- Reproducibility and transparency
- Quality and relevance of references
- Appropriateness of conclusions
- Suitability for the journal
Review Report
Reviewers should provide:
- General comments
- Specific comments on the manuscript
- Confidential comments to the Editor, where necessary
- A publication recommendation
Recommendations may be:
- Accept
- Minor Revision
- Major Revision
- Reject
Reviewer recommendations are advisory and do not constitute the final editorial decision.
Conflicts of Interest
Reviewers must disclose financial, institutional, personal, professional, academic, or competitive relationships that could affect their impartiality. Reviewers should decline the assignment when a significant conflict exists.
Ethical and Research Integrity Concerns
Reviewers should notify the Editor of suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabricated or falsified data, inappropriate image manipulation, unethical research practices, or other publication-integrity concerns.
Timeliness
Reviewers are normally requested to complete their review within 4–5 weeks of accepting the invitation. If additional time is required, reviewers should inform the editorial office.
Artificial Intelligence
Reviewers must protect the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts. Confidential manuscripts, unpublished data, proprietary information, or reviewer reports must not be uploaded to external AI systems where confidentiality or intellectual property could be compromised.
AI tools must not replace the reviewer's independent scholarly judgment.